News 
 National Rural News 
 Livestock 
 News 
 RSPCA slams resumption of live exports to Egypt 

RSPCA slams resumption of live exports to Egypt

9/05/2008 1:46:00 PM
The RSPCA has condemned the Federal Government's decision to allow the resumption of live cattle exports to Egypt saying it's purely a commercial move and does little to guarantee animal welfare.

RSPCA Australia scientific officer, Melina Tensen, says the Government should instead be phasing out the export of live animals for slaughter, "not expanding the trade into regions with a proven record of disgraceful animal cruelty".

"Public pressure forced the Government to suspend the trade to Egypt after revelations of shocking treatment of cattle in that country," Ms Tensen said.

"Vision showed cattle being pushed off trucks and stabbed in the eyes and tendons.

"The sad reality is that cruel handling practices are occurring right now all throughout the Middle East, yet the Rudd Government not only allows the trade to continue but is supporting its expansion.

Ms Tensen says there has not been a proper economic analysis into alternative meat-only trade with the Middle East as a substitute for the live export industry.

"Both the Government and the live export industry also conveniently ignore the fact that during the suspension to Egypt, beef exports from Australia to Egypt doubled to the value of more than $2.3 million in 2006/07," she said.

"While the Government claims the new abattoir in Egypt meets international animal welfare standards, there is absolutely no guarantee that, without continuous close monitoring, animals will be handled and slaughtered humanely.

"RSPCA Australia is calling on the Government to stop stalling and put animal welfare ahead of the bottom line."

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
This trade is just disgusting.

My God what level have we sunk to when Govt's accept cruelty as being acceptable so long as there is a dollar in it?

The Australian Govt puts the reputation of Australia at risk, no change that this Aust is showing the world that we are inhumane barbarians.

Posted by harry b on 9/05/2008 3:10:30 PM
The live export trade is a disgrace to Australia, along with mulesing and the kangaroo massacre.

While we take a high moral stance on whaling, which should be utterly condemned when we continue to have atrocities to animals here.

We continually are assured that Australia has the highest animal-welfare standards in the world, but it took Animals Australia, undercover, to reveal the truth!

How can we ever believe MLA's or Tony Burke's assurances!

Posted by Vivienne on 9/05/2008 4:53:12 PM
Aside from the fact that live export is inhumane and we have no way to guarantee the animals are treated correctly, why wouldn't you spend money in this country giving our people jobs.

A state of the art facility built in this country would supply jobs and we could have some control over the handling of the animals.

Posted by Kerrie on 12/05/2008 6:23:38 AM
Good to see that Australia is taking a lead in world animal welfare by actually doing something to improve it around the world.

By walking away and deserting the industry, we would have no say or right to demand improvements in animal rights in destination countries.

Having worked in the industry in the past I can assure that the standards are high and welfare of the animals is priority.

Often animals on the ship have a better chance at recieving treatment and care than those in the wild as they are under constant surveillance and care.

Sensational reporting, propaganda and industrial terrorism does nothing to improve animal welfare.

Co-operation, involvement and education is a more effective and responsible approach.

Posted by Jim on 12/05/2008 7:01:11 AM
As an Australia, I am sick and tired of cruel politicians who are supposed to lead their flock, to set an example for the rest of us to follow.

How can we follow such cruel heartless people.

The live trade is cruel and there is no excuse in the year 2008, unless of course we are still so very selfish and uncivilised.

Posted by sylvia on 12/05/2008 7:55:15 AM
Egypt has already signed TWO MoUs with Australia "guaranteeing" the welfare of animals and we saw how worthless they were.

Egypt is also a signatory to OIE standards and ignores them without sanction.

This government is even more disgraceful than Howard and McGauran.

SHAME on Rudd and Burke.

Posted by Nicky on 12/05/2008 10:35:57 AM
How much lower can these people sink in depravity?

Egypt is without doubt among the most cruel countries on earth, and by sending them more animals we are encouraging eye stabbing, tendon and tail slashing of dying animals and butchery beyond belief.

Tony Burke and Kevin Rudd should hang their heads in shame.

Australia will never influence these countries and only started pretending to do so when all this was exposed by Animals Australia.

Animal "welfare" workers in these countries is simply animal abusers "training" worse animal absuers, and you can fit them all in a phone box.

Posted by Catherine on 12/05/2008 10:43:08 AM
I am horrified that cattle will once again be shipped live to a country who will never change its ways in terms of animal treatment and handling.

I am embarassed to call myself an Australian while this hideous trade continues.

Posted by Steph on 13/05/2008 6:45:33 PM
Australia now has a reputation as a barbaric nation.

This is a result of the greedy cabal controlling successive archaic governments who are captives of this industry.

Let truth prevail to also expose the cruelty perpetrated on these animals even before loading.

40,000 dumped overboard last year - whilst people of other nations are starving.

These "empire building" savages and their cruel connections should be behind bars.

Unbelievable.

Posted by The Offal truth on 17/05/2008 8:10:35 PM

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Q: Do you support the Federal Government's initiatives in re-opening the live export trade with Egypt?

Yes
(24.9%)

No
(75.1%)

Total Votes: 630
Poll Date: 11/05/2008

6/10/2008 | In journalism there is nothing worse than interviewing someone with TB - True Believerism. But the rapidly changing world is turning traditional ideology upside down, leaving TB sufferers supporting a brand and not a belief.
Subscription
 
Media-Kit-08-09
 
Agrimaster
 
Horse Deals Australia
 
RFDS Dinner
 
Rural Bookshop
 
RASF
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...