News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 Political 
 WA's former political partners at odds in election ... 

WA's former political partners at odds in election build-up

14/08/2008 6:04:00 PM
The WA National Party is on the brink of political extinction, according to veteran Curtin University of Technology political analyst David Black.

Professor Black said the party's only hope of winning enough seats at the upcoming State election to form its desired balance of power was by snatching seats off the Liberal Party.

With the Nationals struggling to survive, forming an alliance with Labor now offered the rural party more hope of winning critical seats than it would by doing deals with the Liberals.

Speaking to Farm Weekly, he said seeking the balance of power was a difficult proposition because the National Party had only two safe seats in the legislative assembly - Terry Waldron's in Wagin and Brendon Grylls' in the central wheatbelt.

There was an opportunity to claim two more seats - Moore and Blackwood-Stirling.

The Nationals stand a better chance of winning seats in the Upper House, he said.

Regardless of the party's dilemma, this election is more complex than the previous three, because the Nationals are a wild card and they would need Labor preferences to win enough seats to get a balance of power.

Prof Black said, "We don?t know what deals they will make in order to survive but if they do anything it will be at the expense of the Liberals."

The stage is now set for an intriguing battle between the former coalition partners to win the support of country voters before the September 6 vote.

Prof Black said there is a real possibility there could be a 'confused outcome' after the election, if Liberal or Labor do not achieve a working majority of seats in the Lower House.

Both parties are going into the election without any support from minor parties, such as the Nationals, and he believes the big two may need it, in order to win outright and achieve coherent government.

"This election is completely different because there's no coalition in WA. Everything is up for grabs," Prof Black said.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size


Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
I'd like to read the whole story because here I see conflicting arguments. On one hand he is predicting the demise of the National Party on the other he says that if the Nats get the balance of power in a close election then they hold the power. Nothing like covering both sides.
Posted by Ian on 15/08/2008 8:38:08 AM
Parliamentary democracy only works when there is a strong government and an effective opposition that can position itself as an alternative government. It's time for WA conservatives to regroup, combine their forces and focus on delivering genuine policy initiatives to overcome labor. If not, then the future of WA looks a lot like NSW.
Posted by Charles on 15/08/2008 10:01:40 AM
Charles uses the words ‘Parliamentary Democracy’ as if to imply that this is a true democracy. “Parliamentary democracy” is Australia’s version of democracy formed by two ‘parties’ whose members, once elected, ‘must’ vote in the affirmative on the decisions and laws of the ‘executive’, regardless of the impact on their constituents or their conscience. The American version of democracy relies on members of both parties co-sponsoring decisions and laws based on opinions expressed by their constituents and individual consciences regardless of the views expressed by their respective leadership. Somebody once said or questioned: what is the difference between one tyrant three thousand miles away and three thousand tyrants one mile away ? It appears that Australia’s version of democracy is only different to the likes of Stalin’s Russia by the allowance of one extra “party”.

Good on the Nationals in WA for attempting to split the good ole’ boys and their party machines.

True democracy is the winner.

Posted by Dr Bob on 15/08/2008 12:44:57 PM
Dr Bob has said that I used "the words 'Parliamentary Democracy' as if to imply that this is a true democracy." I didn't. It isn't.

However, Dr Bob's vision of 'American democracy', by which I assume he means the United States of America, appears to me to be a long way away from the corrupt system which allowed the Republicans to deny the vote to large numbers of mainly African-American voters in many parts of Florida during the first George Bush presidential campaign.

God help us all if that's your idea of 'democracy' Dr Bob.

Posted by Charles on 16/08/2008 6:49:08 PM
Come on Charles you will have to do better than that. Start with the age of the 'United States of America' democracy. George Bush's reign of terror is recent history, and nearly at an end.

In any event, the happening you refer to was more to do with the introduction of the flawed 'electronic' voting system introduced at this time. Stick with the facts, Charles, you might learn somthing.

If you were to read my blog carefully, I did not give a 'vision of American democracy'.

I simply made the point that 'Parliamentary Democracy' is nothing more than Government by 'executive decision', which has more in common with a totalitarian state than a true democracy.

Posted by Dr Bob on 18/08/2008 2:11:02 PM

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
WA Liberal leader Colin Barnett and Nats WA leader Brendon Grylls
WA Liberal leader Colin Barnett and Nats WA leader Brendon Grylls
Q: Do you support the creation of a 'guest worker' scheme bringing in Pacific Islanders to counter Australian agriculture's labour shortages?

Yes
(69.1%)

No
(25%)

Undecided
(5.9%)

Total Votes: 508
Poll Date: 10/08/2008
26/11/2008 | If we're serious about roo farming, we'll need to start with a breeding program and kangaroo EBVs for marbling and tenderness.
 
Fuel Offer
 
Subscription
 
Horse Deals Australia
 
Media-Kit-08-09
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...