News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 Political 
 Bull and burgers: mincing their words 

Bull and burgers: mincing their words

30 Dec, 2009 11:15 AM
HATS off to the year’s most spectacular marketing success, or con job, depending which way you care to look at it: the rise and rise of the Angus beef brand via the lowly means of fast food hamburger mince.

McDonald's and now Hungry Jack's have pushed beyond the marketing aphorism, “sell the sizzle, not the steak”, by flogging a vague and arguably uninformed concept of the sizzle.

The Land newspaper reported in September that the launch of the two “premium” Angus burgers had resulted in McDonald's beef sales soaring by as much as 20 per cent.

The greatest confirmation of that success has been rival chain Hungry Jack's jumping on the Angus bandwagon. Ah, the power of branding.

But also big winners are Angus cattle breeders – to the chagrin of other breeders - as the massive advertising campaigns print on the brains of the great unwashed that Angus is the superior breed of moo cow. Chances are the vast majority of fast food customers seeking something “a little bit fancy” only know the names of two or three breeds anyway and a great deal less about the meat itself.

It’s a dangerous thing to criticise any cattle man or woman’s breed of choice - you’re much safer criticising their religion or even brand of ute – so I’ll play safe and just say that Angus is a very fine breed, as are several others.

The Sydney Royal Easter Show steer and carcase competition is by no means a definitive indication of beef superiority, but for what it’s worth, the Stanhill Trophy this year was taken out by the Limousins with the silver going to Charolais, followed by Shorthorn, Square Meaters (yes, there is such a breed), Poll Hereford, then Angus, Murray Grey, Galloway and Santa Gertrudis. Properly prepared and slaughtered, they are all very fine eating.

Beef taste testing becomes very subjective, as several other competitions can show. What’s more, the breed of the beast is well down the list of what makes a particularly tasty steak. What the animal had been eating, its age and condition and how little stress it experienced in the lead up to slaughter all count a great deal more.

And as for what goes into hamburger chain patties, well, despite the advertising, it’s not actually the prime cuts of prime beef. That sticker on the McDonald’s ads, “Prime Australian Beef“, doesn’t seem to be actually defined as anything by Meat and Livestock Australia.

It doesn’t necessarily mean cattle in their prime, just good Australian hamburger mince which, depending on the season and what’s being turned off, can mean a whole pile of old cows as well as the usual offcuts and less-marketable bits from trade steers.

So there’s actually nothing particularly special about McDonald’s or Hungry Jack's hamburger mince that happens to be made from cattle that are at least three-quarter Angus (the definition allowed McDonald’s by Certified Angus Beef Pty Ltd).

There might have been a hint of what the marketing success was about in this paragraph from The Land:

“Bronwyn Stubbs, corporate communications manager for McDonald's Australia, said Angus beef had come up trumps in its extensive research with local customers to identify what they perceived as a good quality, great tasting beef.”

Perception is a wonderful thing. It was probably helped by the availability of plenty of cattle of that breed with a well-organised breeders’ lobby group promoting them. That Angus burgers were first launched by McDonald’s in the US three years ago no doubt has absolutely nothing to do with it.

So congratulations to McDonald’s, Hungry Jack's and Angus breeders on a well-copied marketing format that has more Australians eating beef.

For what it’s worth, taste being such a personal thing, the best beef has to be grass fed – all that grain-fed nonsense just ads weight, fat and maybe some tenderness to a beast while taking out taste.

The animal has to be prepared well for slaughter – no stress. And then, if you really want something a bit fancy, it will have lived on desert grasses.

Without doubt the best steak I’ve ever had was in Birdsville while doing a story on the Channel Country’s OBE organic beef. I’ve tasted nothing like it before or since. And the breed didn’t really matter.

* Michael Pascoe is a BusinessDay contributing editor, now in hiding from feedlot operators and Angus breeders.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
single page



RELATED COVERAGE

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
I am sickened to see the great Angus breed turned into hamburger mince!
Posted by Tigerdicky, 31/12/2009 6:22:18 AM
And there I was thinking Maccas and Hungry Jack's hamburger meat came from old Jersey bulls with busted pizzles...
Posted by mbh, 31/12/2009 6:58:43 AM
I remember years ago, while involved with one of the duopoly retailers, when Pro Hart (artist) had become a household icon - we brought out a line of Pro Hart bread bins, waste cans, pedal bins etc - all were designed to match the 'hip' orange Laminex kitchen bench-tops - gorgeous hey, now you recall! In the long run, and similar to what may happen to the lovely Jen Hawkins, the product line died due to market satuation. If the other breeds are tempted to 'mince' around with this macro-marketing stuff, I would suggest that they instead ensure consumers have some very vague idea as to the expected quality beef they are blindly investing in at their preferred butcher or the 'corralled' supermarket environment. All the fancy MSA 'feel-good' grading labelling is only provided to our export markets! And silly me for thinking the 'A' in MLA and MSA stood for 'Australia' and its domestic consumers - all those tax payer dollars and producer levies being given to secondary (overseas) markets. Let alone the army of minion MLA expat. executives living the life of Ranjit Singh while being underwritten by the poor bloody levy/tax payers who are lucky to receive $1.80 kilogram for their efforts.
Posted by Clark Goodwin, 31/12/2009 8:49:52 AM
I think the writer is disillusioned with his comments on the Sydney Royal carcase analogy as we all know that is at that point in time to be the best.
Posted by steve, 31/12/2009 8:54:34 AM
Interesting article Michael Pascoe , NC ?. Con of course, if the hamburger joints have sold as much Angus as they claim there wouldn't be many Angus left !!
Posted by foster, 31/12/2009 9:12:35 AM
I would be worried if that is what my breed were known for - hamburger beef! Lucky for the other breeds we can market our beef as quality steak to the higher, more discerning end of the market. Noticed that the big M has now started adding extra seasoning to their burgers - must be to add taste that was lacking!
Posted by solution, 31/12/2009 12:21:59 PM
Oh dear "Solution" you have a big mouthful of sour grapes haven't you? Ha Ha. Am I correct in guessing you may breed cattle with white faces? Nothing wrong with them,except for not much marbling.
Posted by richo, 31/12/2009 5:57:26 PM
Any Angus cattle breeders reading this. Have your net returns improved?
Posted by Qlander, 31/12/2009 6:44:11 PM
What a con. I cringe every time I see the ads. I just don't get it that Angus breeders might be excited about their beef being just mince! Always thought it was much better than that! I hope the breeders have enough to keep up the supplies and they are making a motza out of this (which I very much doubt!) Has to be the one of the biggest consumer cons of the century really.
Posted by Maybalene, 1/01/2010 8:30:23 PM
Oh dear tigerdicky. Do you REALLY believe that Angus wasn't already used in Macca's mince? At the end of the day, who cares what breed is used, as long as people eat our meat. I breed cattle to be eaten. They aren't pets!! mbh, they also make mince out of my old Droughtmaster and Brahman bulls with broken pizzles too!! :) solution, what % of your beast goes to the discerning end of the market? Where does the rest go? That's right, it already goes into hamburger mince too! Get off your high horse, stop being so pretentious and come back to reality.
Posted by CQ, 3/01/2010 1:17:29 PM
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
An Angus bull looks on - perhaps angrily, we'll never know for sure - as some of his one-time farmyard friends fill the buns of a Hungry Jack's Angry Angus burger.
An Angus bull looks on - perhaps angrily, we'll never know for sure - as some of his one-time farmyard friends fill the buns of a Hungry Jack's Angry Angus burger.
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
MULTIMEDIA
21 December, 2009
18 December, 2009
POLL
Q: Did the Copenhagen summit strengthen or weaken the case for an ETS?

Strengthened
(3.7%)

Weakened
(29.7%)

About the same
(5.8%)

We never needed an ETS
(60.8%)

Total Votes: 775
Poll Date: 24 December, 2009

Most popular articles

1) Apple iPhone 4 32GB43 plans 5%
2) Apple iPhone 4 16GB44 plans 5%
3) HTC Desire4 plans 2%
4) Apple iPhone 3GS 8GB33 plans 1%
5) Samsung Galaxy S14 plans 6%

Mobile Phones | Broadband Plans

Get the best deal at Fairfax Digital - Rural Press

PAC - sub
 
FOL EMAIL SUBS


NSW
VIC
QLD
WA
NSW
WA
QLD
VIC

Stock Journal







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Navigate

Classifieds

More Ways to Read

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2010. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...