News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Senator calls on people power to save lower lakes 

Senator calls on people power to save lower lakes

11/08/2008 7:04:00 AM
South Australian independent Nick Xenophon will use his pivotal Senate vote to pressure the Federal Government to come up with water to save the Murray River's embattled lower lakes, its mouth and the Coorong.

Speaking at a protest meeting yesterday in the Murray River town of Goolwa, where about 2000 people observed a minute's silence for a river system dying from the bottom up, Senator Xenophon challenged federal Water Minister Penny Wong's recent assertion that no extra water could be found upstream to save the lakes.

"I say, Penny, look harder," Senator Xenophon said.

He urged the rally, held in Alexander Downer's former seat of Mayo — which will be contested by Liberal Jamie Briggs at a federal byelection on September 6 — to use "people power" and public pressure to force the Federal Government to act.

Senator Xenophon called for an emergency audit of upstream holdings, including those of large commercial irrigators such as Cubbie Station in south-west Queensland, which the rally booed when told it used water to irrigate wheat.

"Why should we sacrifice Storm Boy country so that big business can grow crops in the driest continent on earth?" Senator Xenophon said.

"Why have we abandoned our international obligations to the lower lakes so that managed investment schemes can fatten the wallets of well-heeled city investors who couldn't find the Coorong on a map?"

Senator Xenophon, who was joined on stage by SA Greens senator Sarah Hanson-Young, a potential voting ally, said the Federal Government had to seek out the 350 gigalitres needed to flush the system and see it through next summer.

Adelaide University environmentalist David Paton, who has monitored the declining bird and animal life at the Coorong for 20 years, told the rally that the problem was the result of over-allocation and not of drought or climate change.

He said the Federal Government was potentially in breach of its obligations under the Environmental Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act to manage the area, which was listed under the international Ramsar convention on wetlands.

"Changing the nature of those wetlands from the point of nomination, as is happening to the Coorong and the lakes, contravenes that piece of legislation," Dr Paton said.

He said an allocation system that gave away more water than came into the river was deeply flawed and not sustainable.

The Coorong had had no water from the river system for the past six years, he said.

An environmental allocation for the lakes had to be available every year, not just when the system was in dire straits.

Dr Paton attacked the recent Council of Australian Governments (COAG) agreement — hailed by the Federal Government as the saviour of the Murray — because it put off a decision until 2018 to suit Victoria and NSW.

He said it should be scrapped and replaced with a system decided by an independent body.

Alexandrina Council mayor Kym McHugh said Prime Minister Kevin Rudd should declare a national disaster with emergency powers put in place to buy, divert and release water.

"There is enough water in the system, we know that. He must find enough water and send it down to save our precious lakes."

Mr Rudd, Senator Wong, SA Premier Mike Rann and SA Water Security Minister Karlene Maywald were booed by protesters for declining invitations to speak.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1


Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
It is time to put Nick Xenophon in a row boat at Goolwa and give him a guided tour up the River Murray to its source. Maybe then he would see just how little water there is in the Murray itself. He may have to get out now and then and push his boat over the mud flats but at least he can say he has seen for himself the results of the drought past the lower lakes. As Sussan Ley MP for Farrer has stated to her constituents "without the barrages the river would be dry past Albury". Can we not get that through to the people of Goolwa etc? Has Nick Xenophon had a visit to the River Murray area? Maybe it is time.

PS I spent 23 years living in Adelaide and well remember Storm Boy. However Storm Boy did not have the worst drought on record to contend with.

Posted by farmers wife on 12/08/2008 7:23:13 AM
If Broken Hill's water supply of 8000ML per annum was piped from the Murray to Menindee Lakes then relifted along the existing pipeline you would save more than 400,000ML per annum.
Posted by John on 12/08/2008 8:46:03 AM
It is annoying to see continuing mis-information about Menindee Lakes, such as that written by "John". The only time when there could be 400GL evaporation is when the lakes are completely full, when water is so abundant that the evaporation is not significant. When the lakes are full the water it's not just there for Broken Hill, but mostly for the lower Darling and South Australia. Since 2002 the lakes have varied from nil to 30% full. Evaporation would have been less than 50GL per year. Even now with the lakes only 30% full, a good deal of the water is earmarked for use downstream. Compare that with cotton farms: big areas of shallow water, none of which can be returned to the river for use downstream, and plenty of evaporation. Where is the problem?
Posted by Barney on 12/08/2008 10:07:08 AM
The problems at Menindee: 50,000ML for 8000 is still a lot of wasteage. When is more than 400,000ML, and I am told more like 700,000ML when full, not a waste in Australia?

No "Cotton Farm" (Now wheat farms) has as low a megalitre stored to used ratio as Menindee. They also have to let the first water past for downstream use.

Posted by John on 12/08/2008 3:06:27 PM
I lived in SA for the first 27 years of my life and SA has done little to help itself better use its own water resources (neither have Sydney or Melbourne). What happened to the lower lakes before the barrage? I believe the sea water used to ingress and result in "salty water" a long way upstream.

Remember the Darling system historically only supplies a very low percentage of the Murray flow.

Posted by Bruce on 12/08/2008 8:03:21 PM
And let's take into consideration that Mr Bracks, in his generosity, gave away irrigation water from Victorian farmers who have found themselves in dire straits during this drought because of no water for water stock, for town use.

After seeing our reservoir holdings decimated by Mr Bracks' action in his generosity to South Australia just to keep the mouth of the Murray River open with an environmental flow, I had opportunity to travel through South Australia.

I was astonished by the green everywhere. Knowing full well of the generosity of Mr Bracks, knowing full well that the farms around home have become bare dirt and here I was looking at the lush river flats.

A thing of the past in Victoria.

I have taught my children that they have to manage what they have before they embark on another venture.

Maybe there is something in that for South Australia too.

Posted by Blind Freddy on 13/08/2008 8:28:12 PM

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Q: Do you support the creation of a 'guest worker' scheme bringing in Pacific Islanders to counter Australian agriculture's labour shortages?

Yes
(69.1%)

No
(25%)

Undecided
(5.9%)

Total Votes: 508
Poll Date: 10/08/2008
26/11/2008 | If we're serious about roo farming, we'll need to start with a breeding program and kangaroo EBVs for marbling and tenderness.
 
Fuel Offer
 
Subscription
 
Horse Deals Australia
 
Media-Kit-08-09
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...