News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Family First claims it can fix the Murray in 12 months 

Family First claims it can fix the Murray in 12 months

21/07/2008 10:33:00 AM
Family First Senator Steve Fielding has made the extraordinary claim that the Murray could be saved within 12 months and at a cost of just $300 million.

Sen Fielding has proposed running a 30-kilometre tunnel from the Upper Yarra Dam to Lake Eildon to feed the Murray River with water and thus sustain irrigators and their communities.

"Only a big nation building project like the Snowy can save the Murray," he said.

But he says sending more water to help the critically ill Murray will only be possible if the Federal and Victorian governments also support a $2 billion pipeline from Tasmania to Victoria to service Melbourne's water needs and thus free up water from the Upper Yarra Dam.

The feasibility of transporting the water from Tasmania to Victoria by ship should also be considered, as well as a plan to service South Australia, he said.

The Upper Yarra Dam feeds water to the Thomson and Silvan Dams, both providing Melbourne with most of its water.

"The project to send water from the Upper Yarra Dam via a tunnel connecting to Lake Eildon should take just 12 months," Sen Fielding said.

"The water would flow from the tunnel into Big River then to Lake Eildon, then on to the Goulburn River which flows into the Murray Darling Basin and ultimately the Murray River.

"Within 12 months and at a cost of just $300 million, the Murray River could have about 200 gigalitres flowing into it.

"This year the river had 130 gigalitres, its smallest flow ever.

"Within a year there would be a massive improvement in water flow to the Murray."

Sen Fielding said farmers along the Murray were so desperate to survive they have begun abandoning 25pc of their crops because they simply can't water them.

"They will probably lose 40pc of their crops by this summer and many will be forced to sell their water rights just to survive," he said.

"The plan to pipe water from Tasmania and use that water to service Melbourne and then tunnel water from the Thomson Dam over to the Murray gives these farming communities hope that within a year, their crops will become viable and they will prosper."

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Steve Fielding's comments are the smartest thing i've heard yet, it is so basic and it makes perfect sense.
Posted by Nick on 21/07/2008 1:15:25 PM
Some-one should tell this Wally that the irrigation shortfall is measured in 1000s GLs. Melbourne Water has plans for Big River, but I suspect the water will be going the other way.

Regards Murray

Posted by Murray Maccullochella on 21/07/2008 2:39:55 PM
you gotta be joking... fielding's comments show a complete lack of understanding of the system... silly response
Posted by nickos on 21/07/2008 2:46:35 PM
oh dear, oh dear. And this guy will hold the balance of power in the Senate? At best it might buy a few months, even if they could do the job tomorrow, but a job like that will take years to plan, finance & construct. Put that in the "I will talk to someone who knows what they are talking about before opening my big mouth again" basket.
Posted by trev on 22/07/2008 8:59:14 AM
Is he for real? Has anyone told him the sort of volumes of water he is talking about, shipping it from Tasmania? There is no boat ever going to be built big enough to even provide much more than one megalitre - 1000m3 (1/1000 of a gigalitre), and then the cost of moving this ship from Tasmania etc. Good to see new ideas I guess, but this is not feasible unfortunately, Sam
Posted by Sam on 22/07/2008 9:17:45 AM
Has Mr Fielding looked at a map lately? The Thomson dam is in Gippsland, upstream of Upper Yarra and Silvan. It feeds them, not vice versa. Lateral thinking is welcome, but use some brains!
Posted by shirley on 22/07/2008 9:20:52 AM
hey steve, ever heard the old saying it is better to be thought a fool and keep your mouth shut, than open it and remove all doubt. once we have this 200 GL where to go for the other 1600 GL SA wants for dilution flow and then the 1200 GL of evaporation from the lower lakes, then also i suppose that they need filling first.
Posted by bros on 22/07/2008 9:24:22 AM
Following on from Sam's comment, building a tunnel from the Upper Yarra Dam to Lake Eildon is also unfeasible. $300 million to build the tunnel sounds cheap but what about all the trucks to carry the water down it????? You'll need huge trucks and lots of them!
Posted by Cletus on 22/07/2008 10:09:13 AM
The largest super tanker carries only 500 megalitres which, at the current urban wholesale price of about $300/ml amounts to only $150,000 per load. That would cover the diesel bill to the old 12 mile territorial boundary.

A $2 billion pipeline would need $150 million in water delivery just to cover the interest bill. So it would need to deliver 500,000 megalitres before they even begin to cover the pumping costs and maintenance.

And of course, the Tasmanians will have every right to charge a fair price for their water before it even gets to the pipe. Amazing how the mere mention of water can get some people completely out of their depth.

Urban users have a duty to take all reasonable steps to help themselves before they put their hand out for the compulsory acquisition of someone else's water. They have not done so and will only have started when EVERY urban dwelling has a minimum 20,000 litre water tank. Anything less is the same old "give a country inch, and take an urban mile".

Posted by Ian Mott on 22/07/2008 10:27:53 AM
another baskethead politian who speaks before thinking. 12 months! Yeah right - and at what environmental cost?
Posted by Maree on 22/07/2008 10:30:50 AM
1 | 2  |  next >

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Family First Senator Steve Fielding.
Family First Senator Steve Fielding.

Q: Will the abolition of AWB's dual share system result in growers' interests being put second to those of the shareholders?

Yes
(70.4%)

No
(25.1%)

Undecided
(4.6%)

Total Votes: 351
Poll Date: 20/07/2008
26/11/2008 | If we're serious about roo farming, we'll need to start with a breeding program and kangaroo EBVs for marbling and tenderness.
 
Fuel Offer
 
Subscription
 
Media-Kit-08-09
 
Horse Deals Australia
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...