News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Chinese food import flood ignored by Govt 

Chinese food import flood ignored by Govt

26 Feb, 2009 11:05 AM
The Federal Government is doing nothing to investigate the impact from the flood of cheap frozen vegetables from China on Australian agriculture, a parliamentary inquiry heard this week.

This is despite new revelations that huge tonnages of Chinese produce have swamped Australian shores in the past six months.

The Government's own figures reveal startling amounts of fresh, frozen and packaged foods are being imported every day from China – despite much of the same food being produced by Australian farmers.

However, this week officers from the Department of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries confirmed in Senate Estimates that no work was being done to analyse what impact cheap Chinese imports were having on the Australian farm sector either now, or if and when Australia signed a free trade agreement with China.

An FTA with China has been under negotiation for the past few years, and talks to progress the deal are still ongoing.

Greens Senator, Christine Milne, asked what the department's assessment of the impact of any free trade deal with China was, particularly for Australia's vegetable industry, but the department was not able to answer the question.

Senator Milne took the issue a step back then, asking officers the same question in relation to imports already making it to Australia.

DAFF's general manager of bilateral Trade, Victoria Anderson, said Australia's agricultural trade balance would imply things weren't going too badly.

"In terms of our agricultural trade balance with China we export $3 billion worth of agricultural products to China and import around half a billion dollars," Ms Anderson said.

"So our trade balance isn't doing too badly in that sense."

Yet Senator Milne was not satisfied with that answer, and argued Australian farmers were already finding it hard to compete with cheap produce from China.

"My issue is that Australian vegetable growers are almost being denied access to vegetable processors now because processors can import cheap frozen vegetables from China much much cheaper than the Australian growers can deliver to the factory," Senator Milne said.

"The Chinese vegetables are subsidised by poor environmental practices, and very low wages and frequent human rights abuses.

"Now Australian farmers can't compete against that. Where has that assessment been?"

Ms Anderson confirmed again there had been no specific analysis of such a problem.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size


comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
All for the greater good. Sacrifice farmers for miners. Now this can work, as we can use the loss of production in the agricultural sector to offset our carbon trading - and it won't cost city folk a penny.

Take it a step further and have the food processors close the processing plants, saving money on captial equipment (don't warry about jobs - Pacific Brands didn't) and import the entire processed food from China.

City folks will be happy. They can have cheap food - until the $A becomes the Pacific peso - so let's export the production jobs, so the imbalance of imports over exports can be addressed - how dare we export six times as much as we import.

Better still why don't we just close down and move!

Posted by Gordons49, 27/02/2009 8:21:20 AM
Could not the same comment be made with respect to most things that are imported from China. The issue here is that Australians want first world incomes but want to pay third world prices
Posted by manufacturer, 27/02/2009 8:22:20 AM
What about the quality of this imported product? My wife will not buy Chinese garlic - ever. Says it is such low quality as to be useless to use in cooking.

Will cheap Chinese food be equivalent in quality to cheap Chinese knickers? Basically not worth buying, but there will be no choice.......again.

After having worked in the sector in China, I still have serious issues with regulatory performance and corruption is still an issue.

Do not forget the powdered milk problem of recent times in China. That culture is alive and well.

Pity the Canberra bureaucrats are not realists.

Posted by R See 1, 27/02/2009 9:24:27 AM
Forget about the economics of it. The government is pushing for a fair trading agreement with China and I doubt will budge on this.

China has not yet floated its currency to my knowledge so how can any agreement be fair? It's the quality and what the produce is grown in, that I'm concerned about.

Posted by Will, 27/02/2009 2:29:12 PM
STOP importing foods from China - they may be laced withy poisons. Of course you can import everything China has for sale and just kiss Australian jobs good bye and maybe your health also.
Posted by jaimie, 28/02/2009 3:22:17 AM
Well said, I agree with Gordon's let's move to.... somewhere, leave Australia to the Greens (IMF and UN subsidy NOW Please) put the sign up (Carbon Neutral Of course) and declare the whole lot a National Park !!!!
Posted by Peter, 28/02/2009 5:55:16 AM
Of course this is a massive and on going problem. Try supporting retail chains that support local producers, source as much stock from Australian producers - and obviously I'm not referring to Coles or "we love farmers one day a year" Woolies. Yes, we could all sell up and move (I've always loved the idea of the west coast of Ireland), but personally I'd rather stay and fight for what is left - this country is too precious, the people are resourceful and many lives have been lost to give us the opportunities we have today. Too much to walk away from. If we don't like giving the country away for a pittance, stop voting in politicians who offer such a disastrous vision!
Posted by Andrew Phillips, 3/03/2009 8:44:53 AM
Well done Christine Milne and the Greens. A free trade agreement with China will never be fair to Australia. Unless China agrees to the same environmental and labour laws that Australian farmers have to abide by, we should never sign a free trade deal with them.
Posted by Tom Millen, 5/03/2009 6:59:23 PM
This latest QLD election was the first time I voted Greens. The Greens are the only ones that have realistic solutions, a vote for the Libs or ALP is simply letting the same old hacks ruin our country further. The public are being told it is all doom and gloom but it isn't. We have the answers right now. Thank you to all the Green Senators working hard for my furture but especially and most importantly my childrens future. "I have done seen the light"!
Posted by Michelle Fuhlbohm-Wylde, 1/04/2009 12:50:47 PM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Related Coverage
POLL
Q: Do you trust Government to implement adequate policy changes in their response to the lessons of the Victorian bushfires?

Yes
(9.9%)

No
(85.9%)

Undecided
(4.3%)

Total Votes: 1011
Poll Date: 22 February, 2009

Most popular articles

Advertisement



Stock Journal







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Classifieds

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...